Edwin J. O'Toole Insurance Agency, Inc. is an independent brokerage, not tied to any insurance company or financial institution. Our New York State certified brokers match you with the best insurance products for the best protection, at the best value. We regularly review and assess your insurance program to ensure that you maintain adequate protection, year in and year out. Edwin J. O'Toole Insurance Agency, Inc. is a family owned, family run business that's been servicing Long Island and the rest of New York State for over 50 years.