Penwell Insurance specializes in auto, home, life, and business insurance. Insuring Carmel, Cicero and All of Indiana and Illinois At Penwell Insurance, our priority is helping our customers find the best coverage in order to protect what matters most in life. As an independent agency, we work with a wide variety of top carriers to help you find the best coverage to suit your exact situation. No matter your insurance needs, we can help you find the perfect policy to give you peace of mind without breaking the bank. Contact us for a quote today!